The candy aisle is already turning orange — and one of its most beloved seasonal treats just returned.
Hershey’s Cookies ‘N’ Creme Fangs are back on store shelves for the first time since 2024, and fans who remember scrambling to find them the last time around are already stocking up. The individually-wrapped, snack-sized bars stamped with vampire fang indentations are one of the most consistently well-reviewed Halloween candies in Hershey’s lineup — and with a two-year absence behind them, the demand this fall is expected to be strong.
What They Are
Cookies ‘N’ Creme Fangs are snack-sized versions of the classic Hershey’s Cookies ‘N’ Creme bar — white chocolate studded with cookie pieces — shaped and stamped to look like vampire fangs. Each bar is individually wrapped, making them ideal for handing out to trick-or-treaters or tucking into a lunch bag as a midday treat.
The Cookies ‘N’ Creme flavor itself has been one of Hershey’s most popular since it debuted in 1995. The Fangs format applies it to a Halloween-specific shape that fans have been requesting back since the last run ended.
What Reviewers Are Saying
The reviews from previous runs are overwhelmingly enthusiastic. Shoppers on Hershey’s website described the texture as “unbeatable” and the taste as “creamy,” with multiple 5-star reviews calling them “perfect” and “top notch.” One reviewer coined the term “fangtacular.” Another said they had to “scramble to get them” the last time they were available — a useful warning for anyone who wants to be strategic about buying early this season.
One reviewer captured the full experience: “The kids in our house loved these. They would put them over their teeth as real fangs and try to scare us.” That combination of genuinely good chocolate and built-in Halloween silliness is exactly why this product has the following it does.
Where to Find Them
Hershey’s Cookies ‘N’ Creme Fangs are available now at major retailers. The seasonal Halloween candy window typically runs through late October, but given the two-year gap and the existing fan demand, grabbing a bag sooner rather than later is the safer strategy.
The Bottom Line
Hershey’s Cookies ‘N’ Creme Fangs are back on shelves now after a two-year absence — individually-wrapped, vampire-stamped snack-sized white chocolate bars that work equally well for trick-or-treaters and your own candy drawer. If you missed them last time, don’t wait.
