If you missed the Little Debbie x Nerdy Nuts collab when it first dropped in February, you’re in luck.
The three limited-edition peanut butters inspired by some of Little Debbie’s most beloved snack cakes are back in stock at nerdynuts.com — and if the initial sellout is any indication, they won’t last long.
The lineup includes three flavors: Oatmeal Creme Pies, Nutty Buddy, and Honey Buns. Each one is hand-made fresh upon order and designed to taste exactly like the Little Debbie treat that inspired it — right down to the mix-ins and toppings.
Here’s a closer look at what’s in each jar.
Oatmeal Creme Pie Peanut Butter Treat
The Oatmeal Creme Pie is arguably Little Debbie’s most iconic snack — and Nerdy Nuts has translated it into jar form with impressive detail.
This one starts with a sweet vanilla creme-flavored peanut butter swirled with dark brown sugar and cinnamon, layered over a light molasses-flavored syrup. On top: marshmallow frosting and brown sugar cinnamon oat clusters for that signature Oatmeal Creme Pie crunch and sweetness.
It’s designed to be spreadable enough for toast or apple slices, but honestly good enough to eat straight off the spoon.
Nutty Buddy Peanut Butter Treat
The Nutty Buddy jar leans into the chocolate-peanut butter combination that made the original snack a pantry staple.
It layers sweet honey-roasted peanut butter and milk chocolate-flavored peanut butter over a base of chocolate syrup, then tops it with crunchy waffle cone pieces and chocolate chips to mimic the distinctive wafer crunch of a Nutty Buddy bar. Nerdy Nuts describes the consistency as “smunchy” — a blend of smooth and crunchy — and notes this one is thick enough to be enjoyed best by the spoonful.
Honey Buns Peanut Butter Treat
The Honey Buns jar might be the most creative of the three — capturing the flavor of a sticky pastry in spreadable form, minus the sticky fingers.
It’s built on sweet vanilla creme and doughy-flavored peanut butter, then finished with a buttery honey-cinnamon donut glaze. The result is something that tastes unmistakably like a Honey Bun but works as a spread, a spoonful, or a topping on pancakes and waffles.
What to Know Before You Order
A few practical details worth knowing:
- All three jars are available exclusively at nerdynuts.com — they’re not sold in retail stores.
- Nerdy Nuts’ standard 16-oz jars are priced between $13.99 and $15.99 each, with free shipping on orders over $40.
- Jars are hand-made fresh upon order, so expect some production time before shipping.
- These are limited-edition. Nerdy Nuts sold out quickly during the February launch — if you want them, ordering sooner rather than later is the move.
- The brand notes that products may shift or sink in transit and can melt when shipped to warm climates, so keep that in mind depending on your location.
About Nerdy Nuts
Nerdy Nuts is an independent peanut butter brand known for its over-the-top flavored peanut butter jars loaded with mix-ins. Other flavors in the lineup include PB Galore-O Bundt Cake, Caramel Frosted Brookie, and Dubai Chocolate Bar, among others. The Little Debbie collab is one of the brand’s highest-profile partnerships to date.
The Bottom Line
The Little Debbie x Nerdy Nuts limited-edition peanut butter collab is back in stock after selling out at launch in February. All three flavors — Oatmeal Creme Pie, Nutty Buddy, and Honey Buns — are available now exclusively at nerdynuts.com while supplies last.
